From: Effective coverage as a new approach to health system performance assessment: a scoping review
No | Author | Year | Country | Monitored intervention | Need assessment strategy | Use assessment strategy | Quality assessment strategy | Intervention selection criteria |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Gakidou E. et al [12] | 2006 | Mexico | Skilled birth attendance Care of premature neonates Acute respiratory infections treatment in children Hypertension treatment | National Health Surveys Administrated data | National Health Surveys Administrated data hospital discharge data | Biomarkers Risk-adjusted outcome Content of care (Not exactly mentioned) | Availability of data for 2000 and 2005–06 comparison |
2 | Lozano R. et al | 2006 | Mexico | Antenatal care Skilled birth attendance Services delivered to premature babies Treatment of acute respiratory infections in children Treatment of vision disorders Glycemic control in diabetes Treatment of hypertension Treatment of hypercholesterolemia | Normative Biomarkers Self-reported diagnoses from household surveys | National Health Surveys Self-reporting | Biomarkers Risk-adjusted outcome Content of care | Projected impact on the burden of disease, affordability, potential impact on health disparities, and ability to extrapolate from these interventions to other interventions Data availability |
3 | Liu Y. et al. [22] | 2008 | china | Hypertension treatment | National Health Survey self-reporting | Household Surveys self-reporting | Biomarkers Physical examination included measurement of blood pressure | China’s major health problems Data availability |
4 | Gakidou E. et al. [29] | 2008 | 57 Countries | Cervical cancer screening | Normative eligible women aged 25 to 64 | World Health Surveys self-reporting | Self-reporting World Health Surveys | Second most common cancer in women and a leading cause of mortality worldwide |
5 | Idzerda L. et al. [34] | 2011 | Serbia | Acute respiratory infection treatment | Normative children less than five years | Household Surveys self-reporting of receiving medication | Biomarkers a lab test confirming the presence of ARI before antibiotics are prescribed and again after the treatment course confirming that the ARI has been resolved. | leading cause of death in children under 5 years old in Serbia |
6 | Martínez S. et al. [11] | 2011 | Latin American countries | a) Child Health Breastfeeding b) Women’s Health Prenatal control Childbirth care by qualified personnel Cervical cancer screening Breast cancer screening c) Adult Health (Chronic Diseases) Treatment of hypertension Treatment of diabetes Treatment of hypercholesterolemia | Standard, Single symptom or multiple symptoms, Biomarkers or Performance tests | Household surveys self-reports on care Administrative data records of interventions, drug inventory, Biomarkers | Biomarkers, Self-report, Process measures, Rates of mortality | Availability of data |
7 | López-López E. et al. [31] | 2012 | Mexico | Type 2 diabetes actions | National Health Surveys | Administrative Data records of the diabetes control program | records of the diabetes control program | High occurrence and prevalence rate |
8 | Randive BB et al. [35] | 2013 | India | Institutional deliveries (caesarean section rate as a proxy) | Administrative data District caesarean section rates | Administrative Data Population-level estimates of ID and caesarean section proportions | This fraction was multiplied by the ID proportion to give an effective coverage | High maternal mortality ratio |
9 | Colson KE. et al. [26] | 2013 | Mexico | Measles immunization | Normative children aged 12–23 months | Household Surveys self-reporting | Biomarkers Seroconversion blood spot samples | |
10 | Viviescas-Vargas DP. et al. [30] | 2013 | Mexico | Primary care services for the management of domestic violence against women | household surveys based on questionnaire | Household Survey self-reporting | household surveys | High prevalence rate |
11 | Colson KE. et al. [25] | 2015 | Mexico and Nicaragua | Measles Immunization | Normative children aged 12 to 23 months | Household Survey caregiver recall Administrative Data child health cards | Biomarkers dried blood spots (DBS) serological methods | Vulnerability to imported cases and outbreaks in both countries |
12 | Engle-Stone R. et al | 2015 | Cameroon | Programs to control vitamin A deficiency | Normative women 15–49 years children 6–59 months | National Health Surveys | Biomarkers Prevalence of inadequate VA intake at “baseline coverage” as the proportion of the population that has inadequate intake at baseline and then “achieves sufficiency” as a result of a given intervention or set of interventions. | Prioritizing and coordinating micronutrient intervention programs Deficiencies in micronutrients contribute to excessive morbidity and mortality of young children globally |
13 | Travassos MA. et al. [24] | 2016 | Ethiopia | Immunization tetanus Haemophilus influenzae type b (Hib) | Normative children aged 12–23 or 6–8 months | Administrative Data vaccination cards and immunization clinic records household survey maternal recall | Biomarkers Serosurveys | Conflict in coverage rate of different sources |
14 | Ríos-Blancas MJ. et al | 2016 | Mexico | Hypertension treatment | The prevalence of hypertension Physical examination in national health survey biomarkers | self-report of antihypertensive treatment | Statistical methods two-step least squares method (MC2E) was used using instrumental variables (VI) instrumental variables | One of leading causes of death Burden of Disease |
15 | Luo H. et al. [27] | 2016 | Cameroon | programs on adequacy of folate and vitamin B-12 intake | Normative Women children 12–59 months | National Health Surveys | Biomarkers evaluated the baseline prevalence of inadequate intake and biochemical deficiency of these nutrients analysis of blood specimens | High inadequate rates of folate and vitamin B-12 intake |
16 | Ramke J. et al. [36] | 2017 | 20 countries | Cataract surgery | number of people having operable cataract | number of people with operated cataract | Biomarker presenting visual acuity in the operated eye | leading cause of blindness globally |
17 | Guerrero-Nunez S. et al. [33] | 2017 | Chile | Diabetes Mellitus Type 2 control | diabetic patients prevalence rate | diabetic patients participating in the health control program | Biomarker Percentage of patients in metabolic control [HbA1c < 7%], according to the prevalence of Diabetes Mellitus type 2 at the national and regional level | morbidity and mortality rate guaranteed pathologies |
18 | Nguhiu PK. et al. [23] | 2017 | kenya | Maternal and child health interventions Family planning services Functional antenatal services Skilled delivery and perinatal care Breastfeeding during the first 6 months of life Immunization services Management of diarrhea Care seeking for acute respiratory illness and/or fever Use of insecticide-treated nets | Normative | National Health Surveys Administrative data | Content of care | The recommendations of the Commission on Information and Accountability for Women and Children’s Health Report based on their relevance to national priorities Availability of data |